Lacking Practicality - Executive Order for Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy AI

The White House just released an Executive Order intended to lay down some standards intended to manage the risks of Artificial Intelligence. I absolutely like the idea of establishing guardrails to make AI safe, secure, and trustworthy, but I am unsure that the concepts will manifest into something meaningful.

It appears that the authors have a simplistic view of AI, which if true, can be easily managed. However, AI is more an adaptable set of tools and capabilities. It is not a specific machine or device. It is equivalent to an edict requiring the Internet to be safe, secure, and trustworthy. Great in concept, but shortsighted in the actual complexity to achieve and sustain.

For example, there is a requirement for AI-generated content to be watermarked, to protect from fraud and deception. We can’t do this well in the real world, much less the digital one. If we could do this, spam and phishing would not be a problem. In the Generative AI world, every time a new tool or process has emerged to watermark content or detect fakes, it has been undermined in a very short period.

In general, the document is filled with mostly ‘don’t use AI for bad’ concepts, but not actual structures to govern, control, or penalize non-compliant practices.

At a high level, there is much good in this Executive Order, as it draws attention to key areas that we must manage, including security standards for AI implementation in Critical Infrastructure sectors. The order supports a long-needed national data privacy law that unifies the collage of confusing and inconsistent state rules. It offers guidance for many ways how the government can or should use AI.

These are great areas to pursue, but the rapid evolution and adoption of AI greatly limits our practical visibility and capabilities in how best to establish meaningful guardrails. The result will likely be similar to what has been seen in the past, ineffective standards, with government regulations that are outdated by the time they are defined, and the development community several steps ahead in whatever they want to accomplish.

E-mail me when people leave their comments –

CISO and Cybersecurity Strategist

You need to be a member of CISO Platform to add comments!

Join CISO Platform

CISO Platform

A global community of 5K+ Senior IT Security executives and 40K+ subscribers with the vision of meaningful collaboration, knowledge, and intelligence sharing to fight the growing cyber security threats.

Join CISO Community Share Your Knowledge (Post A Blog)
 

 

 

City Round Table Meetup - Mumbai, Bangalore, Delhi, Chennai, Pune, Kolkata

  • Description:
    CISO Playbook Round Table Overview : 
    Our round tables are designed to bring together top CISOs and IT leaders in intimate, focused sessions. These closed-door discussions will provide a platform to explore key security challenges and solutions. These sessions aim to create a focused, closed-door environment where 08-10 CISOs will dive deeply into the practicalities of implementing specific technologies.
    • Technology Implementation: From…
  • Created by: Biswajit Banerjee
  • Tags: ciso, playbook, round table

CISO Cocktail Reception At RSAConference USA, San Francisco 2025 !

  • Description:

    We are excited to invite you to the CISO Cocktail Reception if you are there at the RSA Conference USA, San Francisco 2025. It will be hosted aboard a private yacht, so that our CISO's can enjoy the beautiful San Francisco skyline while cruising the Bay Area! This event is organized by EC-Council with CISOPlatform and FireCompass as proud community partners. 

    Yacht Party…

  • Created by: Biswajit Banerjee
  • Tags: ciso, usa, san francisco, rsaconference 2025

Round Table Dubai 2025 | GISEC

  • Description:
    CISO Playbook Round Table Overview : 

    Our round tables are designed to bring together top CISOs and IT leaders in intimate, focused sessions. These closed-door discussions will provide a platform to explore key security challenges and solutions. These sessions aim to create a focused, closed-door environment where 08-10 CISOs will dive deeply into the practicalities of implementing specific technologies.
    • Technology…
  • Created by: Biswajit Banerjee

CISO Platform: CISO 100 Awards & Future CISO Awards | In association with EC Council

  • Description:

    Nominate for the CISOPlatform CISO 100 Awards & Future CISO Awards - Recognizing Cybersecurity Leaders. Recommend someone you know deserving of this prestigious accolade....Nominate your colleague, mentor, someone you admire or yourself !

    For more details: Click Here…

  • Created by: Biswajit Banerjee