The Problem of Banning Offensive Technology Sales

The Problem of Banning Offensive Technology Sales

I like the concept of ‘banning’ the sale of offensive cyber weapons to potential adversaries, but what defines technology as offensive versus defensive?

Israel just announced it will ban the sales of hacking and surveillance tools to 65 countries: https://amp.thehackernews.com/thn/2021/11/israel-bans-sales-of-hacking-and.html

Tech is just a tool. It is how you use it, that will determine if it is offensive or defensive.

Is a vulnerability scanner offensive? Sure, attackers can use it to find weaknesses to exploit in their targets. However, in the hands of the cybersecurity team, it is used to identify vulnerable systems that need to be patched, thereby improving security.

Perhaps, such bans should apply to all digital technology. If you don’t trust how potential customers may use a tool, you shouldn’t be selling them anything. But in doing so, you limit the prosperity, influence, and value of your own organizations.

Finding a practical balance is very difficult. Not sure any country has it figured out, but it is something that needs to be done.

Cyberethics must play a more prominent role in our global digital ecosystem!

★
★
★
★
★
Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

CISO and Cybersecurity Strategist

You need to be a member of CISO Platform to add comments!

Join CISO Platform

Join The Community Discussion

CISO Platform

A global community of 6K+ Senior IT Security executives and 40K+ subscribers with the vision of meaningful collaboration, knowledge, and intelligence sharing to fight the growing cyber security threats.

Join CISO Community Share Your Knowledge (Post A Blog)
 

 

 

Turbo Talks: 20 Years of AppSec — What AI Changes, and What It Doesn't

  • Description:

    Turbo Talks is a free 20-minute live session series on agentic AI pentesting and AI safety for security leaders, hosted by CISO Platform. Technology partner: FireCompass.

    Speaker: Ed Adams, Distinguished Research Fellow, Ponemon Institute · Advisor, FireCompass

    Ed is a Distinguished Research Fellow at the Ponemon Institute, founded the Application Security Industry Consortium (later SAFECode), and led Security Innovation as CEO for 20+ years.…

  • Created by: CISO Platform
  • Tags: turbo talks, appsec, ai

Turbo Talks: Safe AI Agents — Guardrails, Scope Enforcement and Governance

  • Description:

    Turbo Talks is a free 20-minute live session series on agentic AI pentesting and AI safety for security leaders, hosted by CISO Platform. Technology partner: FireCompass.

    Speaker: Bikash Barai, Founder & CEO, FireCompass

    As offensive AI agents get more capable, control becomes the harder problem. Practical guardrails and governance for deploying them safely.

    Time: 11:30 AM ET / 7:30 PM GST / 9:00 PM IST ·…

  • Created by: Priyanka Aash
  • Tags: turbo talks, agentic ai, ai safety

CISOPlatform Breakfast Mumbai: Offensive Security for CISOs

  • Description:

    Theme: Offensive Security for CISOs — Validating Exposure at Attacker Speed

    A closed-door breakfast for CISOs and heads of security. Peer discussion under the Chatham House rule, not a product presentation.

    What the table will work through

    1. Exploit windows in days, not months. Edge devices, CI/CD and AI gateways were all exploited within weeks of disclosure this autumn (GitLab CVE-2026-97229, Cisco ASA/FTD…
  • Created by: Priyanka Aash
  • Tags: ciso breakfast, mumbai, offensive security, pentesting

CISOPlatform Dinner Delhi: Red Team Stories and 2027 Priorities

  • Description:

    Theme: Red Team Stories and Offensive Security Priorities for 2027

    An invite-only dinner for CISOs and security leaders in Delhi. Informal peer conversation under the Chatham House rule.

    Conversation starters

    • What did attackers (or your red team) find first in your environment, and what did you change after?
    • AI agents on both sides: attackers automating exploitation, and defenders using agents to pentest.
    • Your top…
  • Created by: Priyanka Aash
  • Tags: ciso dinner, delhi, offensive security, red teaming